Cinephobia

Contents

Reviews

In Depth

Essays

Books

Odds & Ends

Links

Questions


Subscribe

AddThis Feed Button

RSS Feed

What's this?

Become a fan on Facebook

Follow Cinephobia on Facebook



About Me

Update Log

Feedback

Copyright Information



Get Firefox

Get Zotero

Member: AFCA

Member:
Australian Film Critics Association


© 1997-2009

Stephen Rowley

Comments?

Click Here.

Mary and Max: "That Elliot could get a feature length stop-motion film made in Australia is quite an achievement, given there aren’t many made anywhere. That he could make the film so moving is even more impressive. Elliot is dealing with characters that are bewildered by life and socially isolated, and there are tragic turns along the way. Yet he avoids the film becoming maudlin or sentimental, and at its conclusion it is tear-jerking in the best way."

Star Trek: "Abrams recognises that the sheer weight of all those movies and TV shows had made approaching the franchise almost a chore, and neatly rules a line under it all, rendering it irrelevant. Importantly, unlike many other recent reboots (such as the new Bond and Batman films), the new Star Trek doesn’t try to be darker or grittier. It just wants to be better."

W. "A biopic such as this needs a simple structuring idea like this to impose narrative order on the chaotic events of a real life, and such approaches usually risk appearing too glib. Here, though, Stone benefits from the remarkable symmetry presented to him by real life."

Australia: "Luhrmann has mixed up elements of the Australian western (The Man From Snow River), effects-laden war film (Pearl Harbour), epic love story / melodrama (Gone With the Wind), leftist social drama (Rabbit Proof Fence), and more old-fashioned attempts to negotiate Australia’s relationship with its indigenous inhabitants (Jedda), and filtered these disparate influences though the heightened style familiar from Luhrmann’s previous work. Try something like that without it being a little bit of a muddle and you’ve made a bona fide classic. As it is, you do feel the gears change, occasionally gratingly, but what’s surprising is how often it does come together."

Frost / Nixon: "Ron Howard will never outlive the legacy of his populist filmography, child-star origins, and the sheer mediocrity of so many of his acting projects (notably most of the run of Happy Days), but he has become a very good director."

Quantum of Solace: "The new Bond film, Quantum of Solace, is a strange beast indeed. It aggressively imitates the rival Jason Bourne spy franchise; and yet despite that derivativeness, it somehow manages to impart a sense of renewal and vigour to the Bond series. In that sense it continues the work started by Casino Royale admirably. And while it doesn’t always feel like a Bond film, it does feels like those at the helm are actually concentrating."

Wall-E: "The science fiction aspects of the film push both plot and tone in directions we do not usually see from Hollywood films. In its first half, particularly, the film has a melancholy atmosphere and muted colour palette that is a long way from the ultra-colourful norm in Hollywood’s animated films. It is here that the film most recalls the feel of 60s and 70s science fiction."

Tropic Thunder: "The character is evidence of the old maxim that the best comic performances are those that take the comic premise as a given and then perform it straight; Downey Jr has taken this absurd role – playing an Australian playing an African American playing a soldier – as a serious acting challenge, and he nails it."

Persepolis: "You really feel for Marjane, who goes from a precocious and dangerously irrepressible child to a shattered, almost broken young adult. It’s quite a journey, and Satrapi manages to take you along it seamlessly, while weaving in plenty of humour and the story of the fluctuating fortunes of a troubled nation."

Star Wars: The Clone Wars: "It’s not actually that bad, although I don’t want to over-praise it either (and the slightest hint of a positive adjective risks doing so)."

Not Quite Hollywood: "The clips and behind the scenes anecdotes are good enough to make it essential viewing simply as entertainment, and as a straightforward catalogue of the main works it’s also valuable. Those hankering for a really serious documentary, rather than a simple tribute / celebration / highlight reel, might be left a little disappointed, though."

Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired: "The latter portions of the film document the way the sentencing process ran out of control, due to outrageous mismanagement by the presiding judge. None of this exonerates Polanski, and the film lacks the power of a film such as The Thin Blue Line because at the end of the day Polanksi remains guilty and got off lightly even with the sentencing shenanigans."

The Dark Knight: "Oddly, despite all the carnage that unfolds, The Dark Knight is much more fun than its predecessor. And it’s the nifty trick of making such a dark film so enjoyable that makes it something really worthwhile."

Other recent additions: Kung Fu Panda, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, Horton Hears a Who, 2001: A Space Odyssey, Cloverfield, The Darjeeling Limited, Enchanted, Rescue Dawn, Bee Movie, Eagle vs Shark. Or see the full list.



Mary and Max


Star Trek

Odds & Ends

Based on a True Story... "Frankly, it would be nice if a big Hollywood blockbuster would feature some imagery as insane as the shark eating the Golden Gate Bridge, or the very last shot of this trailer."

You There - Have You Ever Kissed a Girl? "The internet, and the forum cut-and-thrust on sites like Ain't It Cool, seems to have bred geeks into a more argumentative, sarcastic breed (a la The Simpsons' Comic Book Guy) than the sheltered losers in this sketch."

Round Up: "I've created a page for Cinephobia on Facebook. This will effectively just carry the existing RSS feed, and be an alternative way for people to be alerted of updates."

Other recent posts: Exhibition Review: Star Wars - Where Science Meets Imagination, Picking the Classics, Exhibition Review: Setting the Scene at ACMI, 3-D or Not 3-D. Or see all the most recent.

In Depth

Is Film Theory Bullshit? "...if we presented many of these arguments to the 'person on the street' I’m sure the verdict would come back pretty quickly: 'Bullshit!' The question is: are they right to react this way? Does this kind of instant reaction perhaps give a true indication of the merit of film theory? Have those who pursue academic theory constructed a giant artifice that simply isn’t sustainable?"

Beowulf vs Animation: "What is the point of an artform that aspires, through the application of highly advanced computer technology, to successfully duplicate the impact of the century-old technology of live-action film?"

Kael: "Kael’s writing still wins me over whenever I return to it. Perhaps it’s that Kael is the rare critic who retained such enthusiasm, rather than being washed out into fatigue by the sheer averageness of most of what they have to review. Kael might have been too eager find extremes of quality, but that did at least mean she was alert to the truly exceptional things that she did see."

For more in depth pieces click here.

Books

The Animated Man: "The first book-length result of Barrier’s years of work was Hollywood Cartoons: American Animation In Its Golden Age, which quickly staked a serious claim as the definitive book on the subject. Yet in many ways The Animated Man is the superior book."

Other book reviews: Blockbuster, Silent Echoes, The Jaws Log, Final Cut, Hollywood Cartoons, Bond Films. Or see the full list.

Essays

Life Reproduced in Drawings - Realism in Animation:"Writing on animation largely bypassed the realism debate. This is despite the intriguing differences between the ways in which live-action and animated cinema relate to the real. Animation, after all, is cinema that belies the founding assumption of realist theory: it is not based upon photographic reproduction of the real world."
Google
 

Published

Click here to purchase The Blade Runner experience

You can read my essay "False L.A.: Blade Runner & The Nightmare City" in Will Brooker's anthology The Blade Runner Experience. For more information about my contribution to this book, click here.

Shop

You can shop for books and movies through the Cinephobia online shop, which includes a list  recommended film books and allows you to purchase pretty much any book, DVD, or video through Amazon.

 Purchasing through the above links supports Cinephobia.